Info point: - Pythagorean Comma

2
BACK TO CBAT Graphic User Interface [GUI]


1
BACK TO ALL INFO POINTS DOMAIN 1

Back to HEMIOLA

Herz Perfect
Fifth Cycle

 

Herz Well Tempered
Fifth Cycle

 

Herz difference between
Perfect Fifth & Well Tempered Fifth Cycles i.e. the 'Pythagorean Comma'

100.000

G

100.000

G

0.00

150.000

D

149.831

D

0.17

225.000

A

224.492

A

0.51

337.500

E

336.359

E

1.14

506.250

B

503.968

B

2.28

759.375

F#

755.099

F#/Gb

4.28

1139.063

C#

1131.371

Db

7.69

1708.594

G#

1695.141

Ab

13.45

2562.891

D#

2539.842

Eb

23.05

3844.336

A#

3805.463

Bb

38.87

5766.504

E#

5701.752

F

64.75

8649.756

B#

8542.975

C

106.78

12974.634

F##

12800.000

G

174.63

Pythagorean tuning preserves the mathematically given fractions for the different 'intervals' within the octave. This makes 'modulating' away from the home key more and more out of tune. Well Tempered tuning adjusts for this by making each of the 12 'semi-tone' steps 'equal in the octave'. The PFC starts with an 'octave' based on 'G-G1' at 100-200 Hz and plots the Perfect Fifth [PF] 'D' at 150 Hz. It then takes D-D1 based on 150-300 Hz and plots PF 'A' at 225 Hz, and so on . . . The WTFC starts with an octave based on 'G-G1' at 100-200 Hz and plots the Well Tempered Fifth [WTF] 'D' at 149.831 Hz. It then takes D-D1 based on 149.831-299.6614 Hz and plots PF 'A' at 224.492 Hz, and so on . . .

When you complete the 12 note fifth-cycle at the these Hz, the Perfect Fifth Cycle continues through G-G8, going from 100 - 12974.63 Hz as an 'imperfect fit' with multiples of 100Hz. But when you complete this 12 note cycle at the these Hz, the Well Tempered Fifth Cycle completes through G-G8 as you go from G 100 to G8 12800 Hz as a 'perfect fit' with multiples of 100Hz.

The differences between the values for perfect and well-tempered fifths in the 'fifth cycle' is shown in columns 1 and 3 where the 'values' of the emerging 'Pythagorean Comma' is shown column 5 of the table.

This is a significant, audible and increasingly obvious difference of pitch [as it is a very out-of-tune]. This is why 'Well-Tempered' tuning was formalized [for example Bach's Well-Tempered Clavier - 48 Preludes and Fugues in all twelve keys both major and minor] in the 18th Century and has been widely adopted as the basis of all music-making since that time.

Pre-tuning keyboard instruments in what is also called 'Equal Temperament', makes 'modulation' between all keys possible, while remaining 'in-tune' in all keys. In other words, by slightly 'compressing' the perfect fifth so we can have twelve exactly equal semi-tone steps per perfect octave, 'well-tempered' tuning makes this twelve-note 'chromatic' division of that octave into a perfect internally consistent whole that is consistently 'in-tune' based at any Hz rates or pitch.

Back to HEMIOLA

2
BACK TO CBAT Graphic User Interface [GUI]


1
BACK TO ALL INFO POINTS DOMAIN 1

Some Responses to CBAT so far

Some Support for the Classic C&C Concept over the years.